|
Collateral Damage and the
Uncertainty of Afghanistan [Please
request permission to publish or reproduce photos. Thanks!
215/473-2162] The following should be seen as an overview of
the recent history of Afghanistan as well as a
reflection of my all too short visit there. We started out for
Afghanistan the afternoon of June 14. Three days later we Early into my visit a young girl approached me
and with a smile from ear to ear, she rather persuasively told me
that I should give her my notebook. Her smile alone was worth ten
thousand notebooks-without a second thought I
conceded it to her. Her younger brother, Ehsanullah Nasrullah,
who is eight, also thoroughly enjoyed attending school. In fact,
he excelled so well that he was many grades ahead of the other
children his age. One morning Nasrullah and his
cousin, Nabile, were running late for class. As they scurried to
school, Nabiles attention was drawn to a small yellow
canister. Thinking it was one of the yellow cans of
biscuits/rations that the US had dropped, he picked it up.
Without warning the When asked what his life was like before the
explosion, he promptly and assertively responded
Perfect! But all has changed for Nasrullah and his family. They struggle to pay the
exorbitant Afghanistan is a country
littered with landmines and other antipersonnel devices. The bomblet that wounded Nasrullah was from a cluster
bomb dropped by the United States. Each bomb contains 202 deadly bomblets, each fracturing into about 300 steel, body-piecing and
tank-penetrating, fragments. A single bomb can penetrate and
immobilize a tank. With ballistic speed, they have the capability
of affecting a 250 by 400 meter region, and individual bomblets
can cover an area roughly the size of a football field. Reports
by the United Nations But amidst the despair, there is hope. One of
the most inspirational facilities we visited was a rehabilitation
hospital in Kabul run by the International Red Cross.. All those
employed are individuals with some sort of physical handicap. The
vast majority of the staff and patients are amputees, some double
amputees. As we walked through the facility we
(The photo to the right is a landmine being
detonated. For size perspective, a tank is situated next to the
red flag at the base of the explosion). We also had the opportunity to meet with the Hazardous Area Life Support Organization (HALO Trust), one of the leading de-mining organizations in Afghanistan and worldwide. We watched as they detonated their 1 millionth landmine-of which 870,000 were from Afghanistan. It is estimated that roughly 5% of the landmines in Afghanistan have been cleared. Although this number is seemingly small, it represents a significant effort and dedication by countless individuals (paid less than $5/day) who risk their lives to eradicate these deadly apparatuses.
Early on, the US government supported the Taliban. They maintained their ties, in part, through the US oil company, UNOCAL. It wasnt until womens rights groups in the US began to lobby on behalf of the rights of Afghan women did the US back off from their public support of the Taliban. By 1998, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia gave the Taliban recognition as the official government of Afghanistan. That support would be short-lived as the Saudi born dissident, Osama bin Laden and other prominent Taliban leaders, were held responsible for the bombings of the US embassies in Nairobi and Dar es-Salaam. For the people of Afghanistan it soon became
evident that every aspect of life, for the vast majority of the population, was going to plummet even further.
Religious icons and temples were destroyed, and most other basic
freedoms, sports and entertainment were withdrawn under the
Taliban. Human rights, especially the Clearly, one would easily equate the Taliban as
a terrorist organization. Their infamous history and deplorable
human rights record stands on their own merits. But,
additionally, the US government knew that the Taliban were
mounting a jihad (holy war) against the United
States, seen as the devil incarnate. Furthermore, the US knew
their capabilities since many within the Taliban
leadership--former Mujahidin--were trained by CIA special forces. Yet despite this knowledge, despite the ongoing
opposition by Womens groups in the west, the U.S.
government justified giving this despotic regime $43 million US
taxpayer dollars to purportedly fight the war on
drugs. Ironically and sadly, Did limited eradication of opium crops occur?
Yes. Yet so did the stockpiling of poppies. In fact, it was
reported that the street price of heroin and opium significantly
declined because of the surplus. Under the Taliban, drug use is
strictly prohibited. But all the better for it to
be used to destroy nonbelievers in the United States.
Furthermore, the question Along on our delegation were family members of victims of the 9/11 attacks. Myrna Bethkes brother worked in the World Trade Center and Kristina Olsens sister was on American Airlines Flight 11. They are members of the group Peaceful Tomorrows, which seeks peaceful resolutions to conflict and terrorism. Together our group met with survivors of the US bombings raids, some of whom had lost as many as 16 family members.
Kabul is currently the only city in Afghanistan which has maintained peacekeeping forces. As a result of the added security, there is an sense of liberation in the eyes of the people. And as you walk the streets and interview people, there seems to be some hope that peace can eventually be realized. From the rubble homes are being rebuilt, stores are reopening, and Mosques are being restored, despite the trickling in of promised US aid. Security and stability is quite fleeting
though, and is especially complicated by US forged relations with
many despotic warlords; some of whom the US swindled into the
Loya Jirga (meaning: Grand Council). They were provided seats in
the council, despite the fact that their had been consensus by
the Afghan leadership against their involvement. An obvious
intimidation factor, many of those brought in were the same
militants who wrecked havoc on civilians
prior to and during Taliban control. The imposition
Four days after I arrived in Afghanistan an errant missile blasted through the door of a home about 100 yards from where we were staying. Most of us brushed off the blast thinking we had heard a garage door slamming. It wasnt until morning that we learned what in fact had happened. Fortunately, no one was injured. But it served as a reminder of the constant threat that the people of Afghanistan endure on a daily basis. Luckily the incident did not deter President Karzais Chief of Staff, Said Tayeb Jawad, from visiting us the following evening. When we met with Jawad he asked that we give a
brief introduction of ourselves. I jokingly stated that I was
with the State Department and followed with a question
concerning the warlords. Jawad responded: I knew that you
werent with the State Department
because rather than I felt that Jawad, an amicable man, truly takes
the interests of his country to heart. Though, as with many
politicians, his ignorance was exemplified by his statements
concerning the plight of the poor. As for myself, and for anyone
who visits Afghanistan, I am sure that Jawads heart is
plagued by: the ongoing US aerial assaults which continue to add
to the enormous rubble already vexing the country; seeing the
remnants of 5 years of some of the countrys most intense
drought epidemic; and realizing Afghanistans consistent placement on the bottom of most economic,
social and political statistical scales--but there is hope. And
that hope begins in part with The attacks of September 11 will be etched in our hearts and minds for as long as we are alive. And although, for many, the emotional pain endures, the actual attacks ended on 9/11. In retaliation, in an attempt to eliminate a massive and ubiquitous enemy, we - the US - have continually, for nearly one year, battered the people of Afghanistan with ballistic missiles and bombs. Each of the thousands of aerial assaults raining down on unsuspecting Afghan civilians are a 9/11" in the eyes of the survivors, the victims. For as we know, not only have the Al Qaeda militants been targeted, but the targets have included wedding parties, clans of tribal leaders, de-mining camps, relief agencies, social workers, educators, mothers, fathers, children, infants. And the suffering, maiming, killing continues. Their pain, sorrow and loss is magnified daily by the terror endured within violent and overcrowded refugee camps, by their hunger, their mental anguish, and their inability to gain access to basic medical care, or even basic hygiene. |
|
|
|
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
In some cultures, individuals believe that a photo has the potential of snatching away or holding captive their soul. As I undertake the arduous task of organizing the hundreds of photos I took in order to circulate them to others, I realized that the photos have, in fact, thoroughly captivated my heart and soul. In their smiles and smirks, and with their tears and laughter is both the uniqueness and similarity of us all. Although the depth of their suffering is immense, so too is their hope that tomorrow will be a better day than yesterday, that the family members they have just buried will be the last victims of terrorism, and that their loved ones still living will no longer have to go to bed hungry, fearful, or forced to endure immeasurable pain.
The victims are countless. Through meetings with Islamic Relief director, Sakandar Ali, it was made clear that the hundreds of thousands of internally displaced, along with much of the current refugee crisis, are a direct result of the US bombing raids following 9/11. Afghanistan already suffers from immense poverty and famine as 70% of the population is malnourished, nearly 80% has no access to potable water, one in 4 children will die by the age of five, and in Kabul alone, there are over 37,000 street children.
We visited one of only 2 mental health
hospitals that exist in Afghanistan. We met with hundreds of
women, children and men who shared their stories with us. Many
were victims of US assaults and were also part of a
victims-compensation program organized by Global Exchange (GX).
The grief of the women was overwhelming, as were the stories they
shared with us. It had been months since Orpha had seen her
husband. He had been working in Pakistan raising money for his
family. He arrived home just four days before the US planes
attacked his village, leveling their home. He along with five of
their children were killed. It was stated to us that the majority of the people outside of Kabul
have no idea who is bombing them. It is Gods will, Orpha
declares. I do not want revenge, I do not hate
Americans... Her humble request is simply for a financial
recompense to help sustain the basic needs of
her family. The alternative for her, like so many other widows,
is begging on the streets. An editorial from the Washington Post
(July 6, 2002) stated that If American forces
prove to be responsible By the end of my visit to Afghanistan, I
realized that the silted rooftops that I thought I was seeing
from the airplane as we approached Kabul, were not rooftops at
all. What I was in fact observing was merely the foundations of
former dwelling which had been laid to ruin. The country is Who are the targets / the enemy? As we have
seen through ongoing conflicts worldwide, it is one that can
never be contained, and possibly never
subdued; but perhaps that is to our governments advantage,
rather than being its nemesis as they would like us to believe.
The impetus of this war was apparently to avenge the 9/11
attacks, but what are the current motives and gains? Clearly the
Bush administration, along with |
Photos by Linda Panetta
For permission to reproduce photos call: 215/473-2162
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
![]() |
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
To take part in a delegation or to learn more about Afghanistan, contact:
Global Exchange: 2017 Mission St., #303, San Francisco, CA 94110. (415) 255-7296 or 1-800-497-1994 or visit: www.globalexchange.org
Resources by Global Exchange include: Afghanistan. An Introductory Reader in History, Culture and Politics. Meet the People, Learn the Facts, Make a Difference. Compiled by Farhad Azad and Nilufar Shuja.
Sources referenced / for additional information:
Ahmed Ghosh, Huma. "Feminist Perspective: September 11th and Afghan Women." January - December, 2001, www.afghanmagazine.com
Atta, Khaldea. "Drought Exigency to Add to List of Problems for Afghanistan," January - December, 2001, www.afghanmagazine.com
Azad, Farhad. "The Game for Afghanistan," www.afghanmagazine.com
Central Asia Crisis Unit. "WHO Special Report." November, 6, 2001. hiebergirardetl@who.int
Hekmatullah Sadat, Mir. "Landmines: Reaping What You Sow," January - March, 2000. www.afghanmagazine.com
Human Rights Watch. "Background of Afghanistan: History
of the War," www.hrw.org
___________. "Cluster bombs," October, 2001
Pierce, Fred. "Afghanistan Faces An Environmental Crisis," New Scientist. January, 2000.
Saba, Daud. "Afghanistan's Natural Heritage: Problems and Perspectives," January - December, 2001, www.afghanmagazine.com
Shorish-Shamley, Ph.D., Zieba. "The Plight of Women and Health Care in Afghanistan," www.afghan-web.com